166k views
5 votes
Nagel’s argument that hostility or aggression should be directed at its true object means that which of the following would probably not be permissible? (Points : 1)

Torturing a prisoner to get the names of his confederates.
Attacking an enemy country’s agricultural system.
Bombing major cultural centers.
All of the above.

1 Answer

2 votes
I would say: all of the above.

In the first case: if the prisoner didn't do anything wrong, then they should not be tortured for information.

In the remaining cases: this would mean destroying agriculture and culture of the enemy, not their military, yet it is the military that is probably the true object.
User Hannah Stark
by
8.5k points
Welcome to QAmmunity.org, where you can ask questions and receive answers from other members of our community.