Final answer:
The statement that the War Hawks argued against the war in 1812 is incorrect; they were actually prominent advocates for it.
Step-by-step explanation:
The incorrect statement about America's decision to go to war in 1812 is: C. The War Hawks argued against going to war, but President James Madison did not listen to them. In fact, it was the War Hawks, led by young leaders like Henry Clay and John C. Calhoun, who were some of the most vocal advocates for war against Britain to protect American honor and to oppose British support of Native American resistance, particularly in the South and the West. New England Federalists and some people remembering the hardships of the Revolutionary War opposed the conflict.