17.2k views
5 votes
Which type of a party system produces the most stable government? Explain why?

User Gilad S
by
7.7k points

2 Answers

6 votes

Final answer:

A two-party system tends to produce the most stable government since it results in a single party holding majority power, facilitating more decisive governance. However, party systems can evolve and stability can be influenced by electoral rules, political culture, and historical context.

Step-by-step explanation:

The type of party system that often produces the most stable government is the two-party system. This system tends to foster stability because it simplifies the electoral choices for voters and often results in a single party holding majority power, which enables more decisive governance and policy implementation. The U.S. two-party system, dominated by Democrats and Republicans, is a prime example where the mechanism of plurality voting ('first-past-the-post') in single-member districts encourages the formation and sustainability of two major parties. Historically in the U.S., third-party challenges have been minimal and have not disrupted the two major parties' dominance significantly.

However, coalition governments, which are more common in multiparty systems, can be more fragile and prone to instability since they rely on maintaining the cooperation of multiple political parties with diverse interests. Examples of multiparty democracies are found in European parliamentary systems where proportional representation voting allows for a greater number of parties to gain legislative seats. Coalitions in these systems must be formed to create a majority government, but these are often less stable than a majority government run by a single party as seen in two-party systems.

Nonetheless, political alignments can shift and party systems can evolve, as history has shown in the United States and other countries like the United Kingdom and Germany. The stability of a government under a particular party system can be influenced by various factors such as electoral rules, the political culture, and historical context.

User Bigsan
by
8.4k points
6 votes

Answer:

The two-party system is the correct answer.

Step-by-step explanation:

A one-party arrangement is, of course, the most stable form of government but not significantly more democratic. The main reason for this claim is that the one-party order does not provide other political groups to enjoy any kind of power or authority. They may exist but they do not have any real influence in the political matters. In this system, only a single party rules and executes all the policies they want. Therefore, there is no liability and administrative reform is very doubtful.

User Josep Panadero
by
8.3k points