Answer: It is smaller than the second star
Explanation: The brightness of a star depends on two factors: The distance from the Earth and size of the star. More the distance from the Earth, the star appears dimmer. And bigger the star, brighter it is.

Where L is the luminosity,d is the distance
Luminosity depends on the surface area of star

Here, it is given that the two stars are at the same distance from the Earth. The first star is dimmer. We can conclude from this that first star star must be smaller than the second star.