11.7k views
4 votes
2. Determine whether the following statement is true or false and then explain wit an example: to downturn the a small town in Nevada lost 20% of its population. However, after a significant improvement in the economy, this same town then gained 20% more people. In the end the town's population was the same as it was before the downturn."

User Aferber
by
8.5k points

2 Answers

5 votes
False.

The first time, when the small towm 20%, the decrease is calculated over the intial population. So the lost is 20% of initial poulation = 0.2 * initial population. And the new population will be 0.8*initial population.

Second time, the increase is calculates over the new population. The gain is 20% of then new popultion = 0.2*new population = 0.2*0.8*initial population = 0.16* initial population.

Then while the loss was 0.2 * initial population the gain was 0.16*initial population, being the gain less than the loss. So, at the end the town's population was less than before the downturn.

When you use percentages you have to be aware that the base over which they are calculated determines ther result. A lower base turns into a greater %.

User Outshined
by
8.4k points
5 votes
Of course, this statement is FALSE.
Let`s assume that a small town in Nevada had a population of 1,000.
When it lost 20% of its population:
1,000 * ( 1 - 0.2 ) = 1,000 - 0.8 = 800
After that the same town gained 20 % more people:
800 * ( 1 + 0.2 ) = 800 * 1.2 = 960
960 ≠ 1,000
In the end the town`s population was not the same as it was before the downturm.
User Hasan BINBOGA
by
7.8k points