480,709 views
35 votes
35 votes
Opinion on gene editing Definition, pros, cons and why are u for or against it

User Guido Kitzing
by
2.4k points

2 Answers

13 votes
13 votes

Final answer:

Gene editing leverages CRISPR/Cas9 technology to change organism characteristics and offers significant benefits, including potential cures for diseases, but also raises ethical concerns, especially regarding inheritable modifications. Utilitarians support gene editing if it maximizes good, while scientists discuss its ethical implications, emphasizing the need for guidelines to prevent misuse.

Step-by-step explanation:

Gene editing is a powerful biotechnological method that involves altering the DNA of organisms to change their characteristics. This technology, particularly CRISPR/Cas9, has heralded a new era in genetics due to its precision, speed, and relative simplicity. Advancements in genetic engineering like CRISPR have made it possible to address genetic disorders, improve crops, and even potentially eliminate certain diseases.

Pros of gene editing include the potential to cure genetic diseases, reduce the prevalence of certain illnesses, and advance scientific understanding. However, there are cons as well, such as ethical concerns about manipulating the human genome, potential risks to biodiversity, and the possibility of exacerbating social inequalities. The debate is especially contentious when it comes to inheritable genetic modifications (germ-line interventions), as these changes can be passed down to future generations, raising questions about consent and long-term impacts on human genetics.

In considering whether gene editing is moral, utilitarians support its use if it promotes the greatest good for the greatest number, whereas concerns include the potential to create new forms of discrimination or affect human diversity. Given the significance of CRISPR/Cas9, it's not surprising scientists heavily discuss its ethics. My opinion aligns with the cautious support—recognizing the immense benefits while advocating for robust ethical guidelines to prevent misuse.

User Froggomad
by
2.6k points
11 votes
11 votes

Gene editing is a process that involves removing, adding, or changing the gene sequence of a living organism in some way.

Pros: Gene editing can be used to remove genetic diseases and other conditions that would negatively affect someone for their entire life.

Cons: There is a debate on the ethics of gene editing on humans. It could be dangerous to do, and could lead to many embryos dying if something were to go wrong.

People are for gene editing as they believe it could help improve mankind overall. Certain genetic diseases could be removed, and people could go on to live longer and healthier lives. People are against it because of the risks associated with it and potential deaths.

User Luca Romagnoli
by
2.5k points