40.7k views
5 votes
Claire is a healthy 19 year-old college freshman enjoying her first few weeks of being on a college campus. She’s made lots of new friends, has been participating in many of the on-campus outdoor social activities, and is getting used to a hectic class schedule. For the last couple of days, she’s been feeling more tired than usual, and she’s had a sore throat. Her sore throat has been worsening, and she also has a low-grade fever and a headache that has been getting worse throughout the day. Although Claire thinks that her symptoms are due to exhaustion, Claire’s roommate urges her to go the student health center just to make sure that it’s nothing too major. At the student health center, Claire is examined by Dr. Peterson. She takes a routine medical history and does some basic assessment of Claire’s condition including listening to her heart and lungs, checking her ears and eyes (for light responsiveness), looking at her throat, and feeling the lymph nodes in Claire’s neck. Claire expects that Dr. Peterson is going to tell her to go home, drink plenty of liquids, and get lots of rest and that she’ll be back to normal in a couple of days. Instead, Claire is surprised when Dr. Peterson tells her that there have been a couple of cases of meningitis reported in students living in Claire’s dorm and she would like to do further tests for meningitis. Claire informs Dr. Peterson that she has received the vaccine for meningitis. Although Dr. Peterson tells Claire that this is a good thing, she informs Claire that they need to conduct further tests to confirm the causative agent and proceed with treatment.

User Alex Motor
by
8.5k points

1 Answer

5 votes
What is the exact question in this case? It is true that if Claire did infact receive the vaccine for meningitis, it is very likely that she was protected against an aoutbreak of meningitis. It is also true that based on the symptoms mentioned, this would mean that she probably has only something temporary and that the miningitis tests would indeed serve only as a precaution. 
User TomFuertes
by
8.7k points