Question

Would plato approve or disapprove of the American system of government? Why

Answer 1

Plato would disapprove of the American system of government because it is a democracy that promotes the rule of the average. Plato favored a meritocracy where the best-suited individuals would rule.

Step-by-step explanation:

Plato would likely disapprove of the American system of government, which is based on democratic principles. Plato believed in the rule of a knowledgeable and wise elite, an aristocracy of the most qualified (meaning 'the rule of the best'), which is quite different from the American democratic model that values the input of the general populace. In Plato's view, democracy was flawed because he thought it promoted the rule of the majority without regard for true knowledge and virtue, potentially leading to mob rule and the election of unqualified leaders. The American system operates on the principle of one person, one vote, and incorporates checks and balances, but it still fundamentally relies on the electoral decision-making of the majority, which does not align with Plato's meritocratic ideals.

Answer 2

Plato would approve of the current government of the United States.

Plato made a difference between the different kinds of the government: democracy, oligarchy, tyranny, Aristocracy and Timocracy (with government owning property) and he concluded that democracy , which the US has, is the best.