65.6k views
0 votes
How did Cardinal Bellarmine respond to the following arguments
from Galileo?

User Lfvv
by
8.4k points

2 Answers

4 votes
He responded by saying that Galileo had no authority to determinan which passages can or should be taken literally and which shouldn't
User Joe Eng
by
8.3k points
5 votes

The arguments that Galileo put forward to Cardinal Bellarmine were:

a. The bible passages about the sun still should not have been interpreted literally.

b. The model of the universe (heliocentric or geocentric) is not matter of salvation.

The Cardinal responded to statement "a" by saying that Galileo did not have the authority to decide which Bible passages were meant to be taken literally and which ones were not. He then responded to statement "b" by saying that, similarly, it was not up to Galileo to decide what was a matter of salvation and what was not. This authority belonged only to the Church.

User Rockfight
by
7.8k points