233k views
5 votes
It is so important in our everyday lives to be able to evaluate if a claim is truly scientifically reliable or not. Often, advertisements will claim to have “proven results”. Can you evaluate if this is a reliable claim or not?

Give an example of 3 questions you can ask yourself to determine if a claim is scientifically reliable or not:

1
2
3

User Drummad
by
7.9k points

1 Answer

3 votes
What is their source?
- they could be a part of a marketing scam
- the key question is: how do they know?
- Who produced it and what background do they have?
- what other studies could the group have produced?

Is the main point of the claim proven by evidence?
- In order to figure out if something is reliable or not, you have to ask whether it makes sense and whether the conclusions were proven
- do the conclusions follow logically from what has been cited, or are they being drawn from evidence that doesn't support them at all?

Do the sources have a bias?
- That doesn’t necessarily mean what they have to say isn’t reliable
- But think about whether they are a witness to facts or are just describing their opinion
User Steve Friedl
by
8.4k points

Related questions

Welcome to QAmmunity.org, where you can ask questions and receive answers from other members of our community.