For this case we have different effectiveness using two conditions the first one with to students who chose the professor as the chair of their doctoral committe and the second is associated to all students and we see a different effectiveness
This is a clear example of an error in the A)Data Gathering Phase
And the reason is because they introduce bias in the study just selecting students who select the professor as the chair of their doctoral committee, and it's very evident when they select all the students the real results change