187k views
5 votes
Which sentence contains a misplaced modifier? The dog catcher said he would return our dog on Saturday. My uncle served steaks on paper plates to his coworkers. The waiter served a burnt piece of toast to the man. My aunt is coming home for the holidays who lives in New York.

User Evelina
by
7.3k points

2 Answers

4 votes

My aunt is coming home for the holidays who lives in New York.

I took the test

User Matematikisto
by
6.4k points
4 votes
Let us first define the meaning of misplaced modifier; it is a word, clause, or phrase that is improperly placed in a sentence which make it refer or modify an unintended word.
The first, second, and third sentences that are given above sound correct because their modifiers are placed just right. Only the fourth sentence sounded awkwardly and confusing, because the clause "who lives in New York" is improperly separated from the subject "My aunt", which must be described in the first place, and not the "holidays".

The sentence will sound and can be understood better if it is written this way,

"My aunt, who lives in New York, is coming home for the holidays."
User Protometa
by
7.4k points