Question

Read Justice Black’s decision in the Gideon case.

Even the intelligent and educated layman . . . requires the guiding hand of counsel at every step in the proceedings against him. Without it . . . he faces the danger of conviction because he does not know how to establish his innocence.

Which of these statements best summarizes Black’s argument?
A. Educated people should represent themselves in court.
B. All people need an attorney’s help in court.
C. Lawyers should not be allowed in court.
D. An innocent person does not need a lawyer in court.

Answer 1

Which of these statements best summarizes Black’s argument?

B. All people need an attorney’s help in court.

Answer 2

B. All people need an attorney's help in court. The Gideon v. Waynwright was a landmark in American justice, being the case where the U.S. Supreme Court declared that everyone should receive legal aid with no costs from a state- appointed laywer; Black's argument that's presented in the question shows his reasoning for deciding about this matter.