111k views
3 votes
Imagine you are a member of the British Parliament at the time when the Declaration of Independence was written. You have been tasked to write a reply to the Declaration, which will be delivered to the colonies. Write an essay (three paragraphs) presenting counterarguments to the key points in the Declaration of Independence. Cite textual evidence from the Declaration to support your counterarguments. Be sure to include an introduction, body, and conclusion to your essay, and keep in mind your intended audience. Finally, develop and strengthen your writing as needed with planning, revising, and editing.

User Dialogik
by
7.4k points

1 Answer

4 votes

As a member of the British Parliament, I would counter the key points in the Declaration of Independence by arguing that not all individuals in society have equal opportunities or abilities, the actions of King George III were meant to maintain order and preserve British sovereignty, and that governments have the responsibility to maintain law and order.

As a member of the British Parliament at the time when the Declaration of Independence was written, it is my duty to respond to the key points in the Declaration with counterarguments. First, the claim that all men are created equal is countered by the fact that not all individuals in society have equal opportunities or abilities. While it is true that individuals should be treated fairly, true equality is a lofty ideal that is difficult to achieve in practice.

Next, the Declaration accuses King George III of establishing an absolute tyranny over the colonies. However, the King and the British Parliament believed that they had the authority to govern the colonies and protect their interests. The actions taken by the King were meant to maintain order and preserve British sovereignty.

Lastly, the Declaration asserts that the colonists have the right to alter or abolish their government when it becomes destructive of their rights. However, governments have the responsibility to maintain law and order, and it is not justified to overthrow a government simply because it does not align with one's personal interests.

User Joanny
by
7.1k points