56.0k views
3 votes
how did the debate over the bill of rights influence the rights that were finally included in these 10 amendments

User Kispaljr
by
8.1k points

2 Answers

6 votes

In the intense political debate that happened, advocates of the Constitution assumed the name Federalists. Opponents, who favored a more decentralized federal system, became anti-Federalists. The two groups strongly disagreed more over means than ends, however. Both sides, for the most part, acknowledged that a stronger national authority was needed and that such an authority required an independent source of revenue to function properly.

Both sides were convinced that the people must erect safeguards against tyranny, even the tyranny of the majority. Once the new government had become an accomplished fact, few wanted to undo the work of the Philadelphia convention. The losers in the debate—the anti-Federalists—graciously accepted defeat; they did not resort to violence. For their part, the winners in the debate over the new constitution acknowledged that the document could be improved by the addition of amendments that came to be called the “Bill of Rights.”

User Romi
by
7.6k points
3 votes
The debate was about a strong national government versus basic civil liberties. If it hadn't been for the debates on the amendments, who knows what would've been added and what not. Thanks to the debates, things like the right to bear arms and the right to refuse to give your home to the army were added, as well as things like the states having the right to decide things that are not decided by the congress.
User Darkisa
by
7.8k points