195k views
17 votes
In paragraph 8, Wiesel makes the argument that “we must always take sides.” What does Wiesel mean by this statement? Do you think his argument is effective?

Practice
Write a response that is four to six complete sentences long. Use examples from the speech to support your answer.

2 Answers

6 votes

Final answer:

Elie Wiesel's statement 'we must always take sides' implores individuals to stand against injustice, and his argument is effective as it stresses moral responsibility. In writing, taking a firm stance with clear reasoning and evidence and empathetically addressing counterclaims is vital in creating a strong position argument.

Step-by-step explanation:

When Elie Wiesel says “we must always take sides,” he is making the argument that neutrality in the face of injustice often serves to aid the oppressor rather than the victim. By taking sides, Wiesel upholds that individuals and society must stand against oppression and wrongdoing. His argument is likely effective due to the moral imperative it conveys, encouraging action and responsibility. This perspective resonates in many ethical and political debates where taking a stance is considered crucial.

In writing, presenting a clear and definitive viewpoint on an issue with supportive reasoning and evidence is essential, as it not only articulates the writer’s position but also engages the reader in considering the arguments presented. For example, discussing the removal of a statue, and whether it might promote solidarity or become a missed opportunity to educate on past wrongdoings, could be a matter for a position argument. Persuasive writing involves identifying opposing views as well, but rather than dismissing them, one should address them demonstrating empathy, showing an understanding of the dissenting opinions while also making a reasoned case for one's perspective.

User Taranjit Kang
by
4.1k points
8 votes
He means that people will never agree, this is the main idea but you can add extra words to make it sound more smart
User PolarisUser
by
4.4k points