Question

(NEED HELP NOW) Determine which statement is a counterclaim for the following argument.

Argument: People in sports are given too many trophies.

Claim A.Trophies are usually given to serve as a symbol of honor.

Claim b.Everyone deserves to be recognized for his or her contributions.

claim c.When too many trophies are given, they lose their value.

claim d.It is important to recognize accomplishments that were made.

Answer 1

Claim B: Everyone deserves to be recognized for his or her contributions can be considered a counterclaim because it suggests that everyone should receive some form of recognition, including trophies, for their efforts in sports.

Step-by-step explanation:

A counterclaim is a statement that challenges or opposes the main claim or argument. In this case, the main argument is that people in sports are given too many trophies. The counterclaim should present a different perspective or opinion on this issue. Among the provided statements, Claim B: Everyone deserves to be recognized for his or her contributions can be considered a counterclaim because it suggests that everyone should receive some form of recognition, including trophies, for their efforts in sports.

Answer 2

D. It is important to recognize accomplishments that were made.

Step-by-step explanation:

A claim (or an argument) is a statement we make about something being true or untrue. Other people might not agree with our claim and offer a counterclaim - an opposing argument.

Here, we have an argument that people in sports are given too many trophies. The best counterclaim someone could offer is represented by claim D. Sportsmen get trophies for their accomplishments, usually when they win a tournament and sometimes when they end up second. Trophies are a way to recognize their accomplishments, which is important, especially considering that sportsmen dedicate their entire lives to sports. This is what someone could say to counter the original argument.