let's take a quick look at the (a , bi) pair, "a" is positive whilst "b" is negative, that means the IV Quadrant, now let's keep in mind that tan⁻¹(x) has a range that lies on the I and IV Quadrants, so, if you check in your calculator for tan⁻¹(x) for those values, you'll notice it gives the one in the I Quadrant, namely 40.38°, however our coordinate pair is on the IV Quadrant, so we need its twin.
Make sure your calculator is in Degree mode.