Question

Toward the end of the book NIGHT, the Blockalteste tells Eliezer "In this place, it is every an for himself, and you cannot think of others. Not even your father. In this place, there is no such things as father, brother, friend. Each of us lives and dies alone. Is this true? Why or why not? explain

Answer 1

The Blockalteste's statement in 'Night' suggests that survival in extreme conditions, such as the Holocaust, necessitates isolation. However, human connection remains crucial even in despair, a theme echoed throughout literature. The assertion captures the dire reality inside concentration camps and the broader implications for human identity in severe trials.

Step-by-step explanation:

Towards the end of the book Night, the Blockalteste's assertion that "In this place, it is every man for himself, and you cannot think of others" reflects the brutal reality of survival in the concentration camps during the Holocaust. This statement carries a strong implication of individual isolation in extreme circumstances. While it may be true in the sense of physical survival where every prisoner is struggling against death, it is essential to recognize that human connection and relationships hold significant value even in the darkest times.

The theme of isolation is a powerful one, emphasized in various literary works. Echoes of this sentiment are seen in the provided excerpts, particularly the idea that even in a social environment like a family or community, there can be moments or situations where one feels profoundly alone. The Poem by Li Young Li suggests that there can be moments when familial bonds strain under the weight of expectation or disappointment. The sense of isolation and the push for individual survival, as seen in the works cited, reflect the complexity of human experiences and emotions when faced with extreme circumstances or moral dilemmas.

Whether this notion of solitude is a universal truth or not can be debated, but it appears as a recurring theme in literature, and it surely was a stark reality for those in the concentration camps of World War II. In the context of Eliezer's experience, the Blockalteste's words also underline the moral compromises and sacrifices made in the pursuit of survival, raising questions about the human condition and the impact of extreme suffering on community and personal identity.

Answer 2

This is not true. At many points during the holocaust, people (particularly children) banded together to escape the concentration camps.