If ABCD is a kite, then by definition it has two pairs of congruent sides.
Let point C has coordinates (a,b).
Then
Solve the system of equations:

Square these two equations and then subtract:

Substitute b=5 into the first equation:

You get two points (1,5) and (-1,5). Point (-1,5) coincides with point A, so C(1,5).
Answer: correct choice is B.