Answer:

Explanation:
First it is necessary to perform the operations indicated in the parentheses.

Next, we will pass the terms with literal to the right side of the equation, and the constant terms to the left side. Remember that when changing side of equality, they change sign.

Now we will perform the indicated addition and subtraction operations

About charlie's equation

We can see that Charlie's solution is not correct. You had an error in a sign that affects the entire equation.