Answer: A
Explanation: In artificial selection, humans determine what traits get passed down. For B, humans play no role in where the fish lays her eggs. For C, humans aren’t the ones killing the deer and rabbits — natural predators are. As a result, humans play no role. For D, humans also play no role in deciding which penguin lives.
For A, however, humans have caused African elephants to naturally lack tusks because of their hunting — this wasn’t natural or due to the environment. This was due to human intervention. As a result, it is artificial selection.