87.8k views
2 votes
How did the white South's intransigence and President Johnson's political bungling open the way for congressional Republican program of military Reconstruction?

User Hugot
by
8.2k points

2 Answers

6 votes

Final answer:

President Johnson's lenient approach to Reconstruction and conflict with Congressional Republicans led to the Radical Republican's control and a military Reconstruction that aimed to protect freedmen's rights. Despite initial efforts and the Fifteenth Amendment, Reconstruction ended with the withdrawal of Union troops in 1877. The clash resulted in Johnson's impeachment and the election of President Ulysses S. Grant.

Step-by-step explanation:

The intransigence of the white South and President Johnson's political bungling played significant roles in shaping the trajectory of Reconstruction after the Civil War. President Johnson's approach, following Lincoln's assassination, aimed for swift reintegration of the Southern states with relatively lenient terms. This stance, coupled with his political missteps and confrontation with Republicans in Congress — who were pushing for greater rights for the freed people and a thorough Reconstruction of the South — led to a significant conflict. Johnson's inability to work collaboratively with Congress and the stubbornness of Southern whites in resisting changes that aimed to eliminate the vestiges of slavery allowed Radical Republicans to take control and implement a military Reconstruction program, which involved federal enforcement of rights for freedmen and rebuilding the Southern political and social systems.

Radical Republicans, advocating for a more equal society, saw the need to push their program forward, leading to the ratification of the Fifteenth Amendment, granting black men the right to vote. Yet, despite these measures, the efforts put forth by the Republicans could not sustain the long-term objective of an interracial democracy that provided equal rights to all citizens, as Reconstruction ended with the withdrawal of Union troops in 1877.

The clash between President Johnson's lenient approach and the Radical Republicans' push for a transformative Reconstruction led to the impeachment of Johnson, though he narrowly avoided removal from office. Ultimately, Ulysses S. Grant won the presidency with the promise of peace, marking a pivotal turn in the nation's effort to reconstruct.

User Casey Fleser
by
7.5k points
4 votes

Presidents Abraham Lincoln and Andrew Johnson adopted moderate positions to return the South to the Union as quickly as possible, while the Radical Republicans in Congress sought stronger measures to improve the rights of African-Americans, including the Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitution. The United States. Lincoln's speeches show that he was inclined to support the freedom of vote of all freedmen, while Johnson opposed this.

The end of Reconstruction was a staggered process, and the period of republican control ended at different times in different states. With the Compromise of 1877, military intervention in southern politics ceased and Republican control collapsed in the last three state governments in the south. This was followed by a period that white southerners called "Redemption," during which state legislatures dominated by whites enacted Jim Crow laws and, beginning in 1890, deprived most African-Americans and many poor whites of one combination of constitutional amendments and electoral laws. The white memory of the Reconstruction of the Southern Democrats played an important role in the imposition of the white supremacy system of segregation, of second-class citizenship for African Americans who use laws known as Jim Crow laws.

User Marcin Wasilewski
by
9.0k points