70.1k views
2 votes
Theodore Roosevelt moved to break up trusts he decided worked against the public interest, while allowing trusts to stay together if they charged what he decided were fair prices. Consider this political cartoon from the time: Would you consider this cartoon to be supportive of Roosevelt’s efforts? Why or why not? What message is being sent about the bear marked “good trusts”?

User Bendrix
by
6.8k points

2 Answers

2 votes

Supportive—Roosevelt is depicted as someone who is hunting potentially dangerous wild animals (trusts)

Not supportive—Roosevelt could be interpreted to be an aggressor that only spares trusts that bend to his will.

Trusts that behave themselves as far as Roosevelt is concerned will be spared.

User Blackhex
by
7.1k points
5 votes

The cartoon “The President´s Dream of a Successful Hunt” of 1907 by Clifford Berryman depicts Theodore Roosevelt´s view about how he would stop the “bad trusts”, and only keep the “good trusts” by means of a political restraint. The cartoon shows this conception by showing a hunted bear with the mark of bad trusts, and a bear with the mark of good trusts being held by Roosevelt with a belt representing the restraint.

The cartoon is supportive of Roosevelt´s efforts since it shows an aggressive way of cleaning the country of what he considered bad trusts, whose business practices were bad for the public interest, and only keeping the good ones. The president promoted this cleanse by proposing the Sherman Antitrust Act in 1890, which basically provided him the with the ultimate decision to dismantle a monopoly or not. Such case of a good trust that was left alone was the American Sugar Refining Company, and a case of bad trust that was demolish was the Northern Securities Company.

The bear labeled as “good trusts” shows a frightened mood that represents the feeling that the, not so corrupt, monopolies should have felt facing such steady and firm law of the president. This frightened bear contrasts with the bear on the right, which is not worried about the antitrust act since its being left alone and not hunted. This bear represents an honest, and benefic corporation for the country.


Theodore Roosevelt moved to break up trusts he decided worked against the public interest-example-1
User Ernie
by
6.5k points