Question

why was ellis island call by some the “Golden door” to America why did others call it the isle of tears what do you think is better description and why

Answer 1

Ellis Island was a symbol of hope as the 'Golden Door' to America for many immigrants, but also a place of heartache, known as the 'Isle of Tears', for those who faced rejection. Whether it is seen as one or the other largely depends on individual experiences and the duality of the immigration process. The Alcatraz Proclamation reflects Native American perspectives on historic injustices and contemporary issues facing their communities.

Step-by-step explanation:

Ellis Island was dubbed the “Golden Door” because it was seen as the gateway to a land of opportunity for millions of immigrants seeking a new life in America. Yet, for others, it was known as the “Isle of Tears” due to the emotional hardship of the immigration process, including strict health inspections and the possibility of being turned away. These differing views highlight the complex nature of the American immigration experience at the turn of the 20th century, with Ellis Island symbolizing both hope and despair.

Upon entrance to Ellis Island, those with less means, who traveled in steerage, underwent thorough medical exams and questioning. An unfortunate few were denied entry into the United States due to medical conditions or legal issues, leading to painful separations and the nickname “Isle of Tears”. Nevertheless, for the majority who entered the country, Ellis Island was a symbol of new beginnings and the American Dream. Therefore, whether the “Golden Door” or “Isle of Tears” is a better description depends on the personal experiences of each immigrant.

The Alcatraz Proclamation sheds light on how some Native Americans perceive their history—a profound sense of loss and resentment toward the treatment and conditions imposed on them by U.S. policy.

Answer 2

Step-by-step explanation:

The people who called it the golden door, usually hadn't experienced the harsh reality of the island. They were usually people who wanted to go to America, but could not afford it, or didn't have the right circumstances. The people that called it the isle of tears had either been there or heard the stories of what it was really like. Ellis Island was full of sadness, hunger, and fear. I think the isle of tears is a better description because the immigrants on the island did cry, in fact, they cried often. The golden door to America is not a realistic version of the island. The island was a door to America, but not a golden one. Therefore the isle of tears is a more fitting name.