The right answer is: "do not make my love look older"
In the above exclamation, Shakespeare pleads for time not cause a lover's clear forehead to wrinkle using figurative language (O! carve not with thy hours my love's fair brow).
"Keep time from passing" seems a better paraphrase for the fragment "ever live young" on the last line; "time cannot alter my love" is a statement which may better define the main theme of the poem; and "my love has beautiful brows" addresses a personal opinion which lacks support in the poem.
As a result only the fourth option can be correct.