Question

Why do the young men on the train bind, gag, and beat Mrs. Schächter?

Select each correct answer.


They cannot endure her fearful screaming.


They do not want her to know about the fire.


She has made accusations against too many of them.


She voices aloud the terror they all feel inside.

Answer 1

The young men on the train silence Mrs. Schächter to end the disturbance caused by her screams and possibly to quell a terror that they all internally feel.

Step-by-step explanation:

The young men on the train bind, gag, and beat Mrs. Schächter because they cannot endure her fearful screaming, which disturbs the oppressive and tense environment of the train carriage. Additionally, her vocal expressions of terror might reflect the internalized fears of the passengers, adding to the sense of desperation and discomfort among them. Although not explicitly stated in these excerpts, such actions typically arise out of a combination of the desire to silence a disturbing element and a shared fear of facing the terrible reality that they might all be trying to suppress.

Answer 2

They cannot endure her fearful screaming. AND She voices aloud the terror they all feel inside.

Mrs. Schachter is in the cattle car with other Jewish people who have been rounded up by the Nazis. The people do not know where they are being taken. The way they've been treated so far by the soldiers indicates that it probably won't be a happy place. Mrs. Schachter's reactions to being crammed into the cattle car with many other people and being hauled off to likely a terrible place mirrors what the others are feeling. They are afraid for what is to come. Also, her screaming is so terrible and consistent that it scrapes at the people's minds. They cannot take her behaviors any more so they bind, gag, and beat her. Later, they find out Mrs. Schachter is right. They do get off the train at Auschwitz where people are being gassed in chambers and the bodies are burned in furnaces.