Answer: "The (1846) crack" is what both sentences have in common, therefore we can combine them like this:
Since it could not be fixed, the Liberty Bell has had that crack in it ever since.
The correct answer is: "That crack could not be fixed, so the Liberty bell has had it ever since."
or, alternatively "The Liberty Bell has had that unfixable crack ever since".
9.5m questions
12.2m answers