The correct answer is option The students used different ranges for their y axes.
The range of the Y axis shows the variation in the experimental condition. The range on each axis should be chosen in such a way that the data is reflected properly. The changes in the portion of the Y axis can change the conclusion dramatically.
In this case, Jake must have chosen a range, which is very large, so, the changes in smaller quantity does not result in significant impact on the graph. In case of Aisha, the range must be very small, due to which a smaller change in the range create a major impact on the graph.