150k views
1 vote
What impact did Thoreau have on Lewis? How does Lewis respond to some of Thoreau’s ideas?

User Swbbl
by
8.4k points

2 Answers

4 votes

Lewis was influenced by Thoreau’s form of civil disobedience. Like Thoreau, Lewis believes that if a law is corrupt, a man should not be ashamed of breaking it and then getting arrested and jailed on account of it. Lewis, again like Thoreau, believes in taking a stand against injustice through a public demonstration. This is evident in the lines, “I felt that any form of action, any form of drama of this kind, was helpful and effective. I think that whenever you can get a large group of people together, whether it's to march, or to have a prayer vigil, or to sit in, you should.”

Also like Thoreau, Lewis believes in protesting in a nonviolent way, as seen in the lines that reference Malcolm X: “Malcolm was not part of the movement. The movement had a goal of an integrated society, an interracial democracy, a Beloved Community. What Malcolm X represented were the seeds of something different, something that would eventually creep into the movement itself and split it apart . . . To his credit, he preached personal independence and responsibility, self-discipline and self-reliance. But he also urged the black man to fight back in self-defense—‘by any means necessary,’ as he famously put it. And I just could not accept that.” John Lewis implicitly states that nonviolent civil disobedience was the answer to the civil rights movement. This notion, as well as the promotion of “self-discipline and self-reliance," are ideas Lewis shares with Thoreau.

User Nazar Sakharenko
by
8.6k points
1 vote

Thoreau’s form of civil disobedience influenced Lewis. Lewis’ belief, like Thoreau, is that a law is corrupt, then man shouldn’t be guilty of breaking the law and then getting jailed and arrested based on the account on it. Again, like Thoreau, Lewis also believes in holding firm against injustice thru the means of a public demonstration.

User Lakshay Sharma
by
8.1k points