Final answer:
The reduction in genetic variation within the northern elephant seal population due to intense hunting is best explained by genetic drift (Option C), particularly the bottleneck effect.
Step-by-step explanation:
The change in gene frequency within the northern elephant seal population after a dramatic population decrease due to hunting in the 1890s can be best explained by the concept of genetic drift, specifically a scenario known as the bottleneck effect. This occurs when a significant event, whether natural or human-caused, drastically reduces the size of a population, leaving a small, random sample of individuals to contribute their genes to future generations. The result is a population with substantially less genetic variation, as many alleles present in the original population may be lost. On the other hand, the founder effect relates to a new population being started by a small group of individuals, influencing genetic frequencies in a different context.