131k views
2 votes
Write a dissenting opinion for the Dred Scott decision. Base your opinion on the facts in the case and rights guaranteed by the Constitution of the United States

User Tiagojco
by
5.8k points

2 Answers

5 votes

He should have been freed because he was considered a slave and one state and not the other, they should have had free slaves be nationaly recongized, instead of having them be a free slave in one state, they should be a free slave in all states, their status shouldn't change just because they are going into another state's territory.

User Rafael Angarita
by
5.5k points
1 vote

Answer:

my opinion is that Dred scott decision was not far and that the slave should have been free it a good thing now this day we don't ave slaves

Step-by-step explanation:

User SpectralWave
by
5.2k points