Answer: The first study was an observational study whereas the second was a controlled experiment.
Explanation:
A study that record the characteristics of a population by studying individuals in a sample, but does not manipulate variables of interest is known as an operational study. Like in the first study only effects have been noted.
A controlled experiment is an experiment where the variable of interest is directly manipulated by a scientist, in order to test a single variable at a time.
Like in the second study, the subjects were under the control of the experimenter, to test the effect of oil.
The first study was an observational study whereas the second was a controlled experiment.