Question

The Communists drew up a constitution that, according to the text, asserted (claimed) that "all

political power, resources, and means of production would belong to workers and peasants."
How truthful was this assertion (claim)? How do you think this affected the credibility of the
Soviet Union?

Answer 1

The Soviet Union claimed political power and production means belonged to workers and peasants, but this was not entirely truthful due to economic stagnation, centralized political control, and human rights violations. This affected its credibility negatively.

Step-by-step explanation:

The Communists, upon drafting a constitution, claimed that "all political power, resources, and means of production would belong to workers and peasants." However, this assertion didn't align well with the realities within the Soviet Union. Despite the ideological goals of communism which envisioned a classless society where the workers would control the means of production, the USSR experienced significant economic stagnation and inequality.

In practice, political power was centralized in the hands of the Communist Party, led by the apparatchiks. This divergence between the theory of Marxism-Leninism and its implementation within the Soviet Union affected its credibility. The Soviet state maintained control through various methods, including political purges and surveillance, which eventually led to the disenchantment of many citizens and contributed to its eventual dissolution.

Furthermore, while Marxism-Leninism advocated for peaceful governance and an end to imperialism, the Soviet Union placed a high emphasis on military might and exerted control over Eastern European 'allied' nations post-World War II. This contradiction between the communist doctrine and the USSR's actions was an undermining factor to its credibility both domestically and internationally.

The gap between the ideological promises of communism and the lived reality under the Soviet Union's rule led to a crisis of credibility. The proponents of communism claimed adherence to Marx's ideology which was essential for legitimizing the party's actions. Still, the oppressive nature of the regime, human rights violations, and lack of true democratic structures led many within and outside the USSR to question its legitimacy and the feasibility of its model of governance.

Answer 2

This claim was not truthful because jt is an example of propaganda put out by Stalin. He would constantly try to pin different classes against each other which was what made statements such as these not credible.