59.1k views
4 votes
Write a 500-word comparative essay comparing the setting of Eugenia Collier’s short story “Marigolds” to a painting or photograph taken during the Great Depression.

Explore Depression Era artwork by conducting a short research through approved school sites.
Choose a work of art to use in your comparative essay. Provide copy of the image in your essay, as well as the Web site url where you viewed the artwork.
Use the Graphic Organizer to help you collect your ideas for your essay.
Credit your sources within your essay using in-text citations and include a works-cited list using the format provided in the MLA Style Guide.
Use at least two sources: one will be your chosen artwork, the other will be the short story “Marigolds.” You may use additional books or Web sites (credible information and reliable sites include those in *.gov and *.edu domains).

1 Answer

4 votes

Answer:

The story tells of a young African-American girl named Lizabeth who grew up during the Great Depression. In the beginning of the story, she is very childish and does not stop to think about her actions. With their friends, Lizabeth and her brother go to the house of an elderly woman named Ms. Lottie and harass her while she tends to her marigolds by throwing stones at the marigolds and yelling rude things at her. They also make fun of Miss Lottie's mentally disabled son, John Burke. As they run away from Miss Lottie's house after calling her an "old lady witch", Lizabeth begins to think about her actions and how they affect others. Later that night, Lizabeth hears her parents argue about jobs and money and talk about how they feel they can't support themselves. Lizabeth's mother works to support her family, but her father is out of a job and is upset because he believes that he, as the man of the house, should earn the money for the family. Out of shock and anger, Lizabeth sneaks over to Miss Lottie's house. She goes to the garden to destroy all the marigolds in a rage, only to come face-to-face with the old woman. Miss Lottie sees what Lizabeth has done to her flowers, and she is so shocked that she doesn't say or do anything. As Lizabeth realizes that the marigolds she destroyed were the only bit of hope and beauty Miss Lottie had left, she starts to regret her actions and begs Miss Lottie to forgive her. In the present, Lizabeth, who is now an adult, looks back on her childish actions with regret and states that their encounter was the end of her innocence and of her childhood. In the end, Lizabeth finally understands that the marigolds meant to be a symbol of hope even in rough times, and she has planted some of her own in Miss Lottie's memory.

Step-by-step explanation:

User Gelliant
by
5.7k points