228k views
1 vote
Compose an essay that argues which health care system is better in terms of economics. Analyze the reasons for your determination by covering these points:

scarcity and allocation of resources
incentives
role of the government
how prices are determined
benefits and drawbacks for consumers in the UK and US
benefits and drawbacks for producers in the UK and the US
Be sure to include specific reference to sources and a counterargument. Your essay should include an introduction, transitions, and a conclusion.

User Shanese
by
4.5k points

2 Answers

1 vote

Answer:

In terms of economics, both healthcare systems have major issues. The US and the UK both have

problems that arise in the health department. I can't say which is better because I have only been treated

by the US, but after extensive research I can honestly say that I would much rather have the healthcare

system that is in the United Kingdom. I'd much rather deal with the problems of free healthcare, than

extremely expensive healthcare. Due to my age, I have not yet had to deal with the problems in this

system, but I know someday I will.

In the US, most people know how expensive being treated for a medical condition can be without proper

insurance. This is a major economic issue we face in this country. As stated by YouGov, "Americans who

viewed the US system as not favorable thought that healthcare was too expensive and unfair on poorer

citizens, with insurers sometimes refusing to pay out." Wealthier people are favored over the poor. Many

people lack health insurance. This leads to a large portion of Americans who have no jobs, have no

insurance and in turn, are not able to get any medical services. This is actually great for the government,

because they end up paying less for health care services and products. The US government chooses to

spend their money elsewhere.

The UK doesn't have this problem because of it's free healthcare. But that doesn't mean that it doesn't face

other issues. Since profit is not the main incentive behind the NHS, and prices do not play the same role as

in a free market system, inefficiencies exist. The power of a competitive market suggests that the correct

quantity and quality of health care would be provided at minimal cost to meet consumer demand. This is

not the case for the NHS. They expect doctors to act in their best interests but this may not happen in a

free market. A doctor working for a company motivated by profit may act their best when deciding how to

treat a patient.

Health care in the US is provided by many separate legal entities both in the private and in the public

sector. This is a free market system , where anyone, regardless, can provide health care. It therefore

increases the competitive level of health care to consumers, increasing economic efficiency. In order for

them to stay in the market, they each need to maximize the quality of their products and lower the

costs. Furthermore, the US has some of the best medical research systems.

In the UK, the main aim of the NHS is to provide a high quality service available on the basis of clinical need

and not ability to pay'. It is also a huge job provider. It increases the productivity of the economy by keeping

the workforce healthy It also increases GDP by raising life expectancy and therefore lengthening the

average working life.

In conclusion, neither system is perfect and it is your opinion whether you think the US healthcare system

is better than the UK's. But I definitely think the system held in the UK works better. Their government truly

cares about every single persons life, despite some of them being poor. Yes, they spend more more money

on the health care services and products than the US, but that is actually a good thing in my opinion.

Step-by-step explanation:

User David Sette
by
4.6k points
3 votes

Answer: I think that the US healthcare system is the better in terms of economics because it is private and the wait time is shorter. The healthcare is private like Medicare and Medicaid which provide certain services to certain segments in US.Since they are private the workers and health facilities are also privet while in the UK they are public. Another plus of them being private is faster treatment and more advanced technologies, which in turn makes them very reliable to the US. This brings me to my next point on how the times for are shorter than the UK. In the UK sometimes people with have to wait months and maybe years to get certain treatments they need. In the US the wait time could be in a few days or a few weeks.

Hope its the works have a nice day :)

User Vidit
by
4.3k points