Question

Do you believe the Old Settlers made the right choice in moving to the west before the Indian Removal Act? Explain your answer

Answer 1

Answer 1 with Explanation

Indeed it was the from the right off the bat in the nineteenth century, while the quickly becoming United States ventured into the lower South, white pioneers confronted what they thought about an obstruction. This region was home to the Cherokee, Creek, Choctaw, Chickasaw, and Seminole countries. These Indian countries, in the perspective on the pioneers and numerous other white Americans, were obstructing progress. Excited for land to raise cotton, the pilgrims influenced the national government to gain an Indian area.

Answer 2 with Explanation

Andrew Jackson, from Tennessee, was a compelling advocate of Indian expulsion. In 1814 he told the U.S. military powers that vanquished a group of the Creek country. In their annihilation, the Creeks lost 22 million sections of land of land in southern Georgia and focal Alabama. The U.S. obtained more land in 1818 when, impelled to some extent by the inspiration to rebuff the Seminoles for their routine with regards to harboring outlaw slaves, Jackson's troops attacked Spanish Florida.

Different endeavors included surrendering bits of their property to the United States with the end goal of holding authority over in any event part of their domain, or of the new region, they got in return. Some Indian countries basically wouldn't leave their property - the Creeks and the Seminoles even battled to secure their region. The First Seminole War kept going from 1817 to 1818. The Seminoles were supported by outlaw slaves who had discovered insurance among them and had been living with them for quite a long time. The nearness of the escapees maddened white grower and energized their longing to overcome the Seminoles.

Answer 2

I think that several factors somehow forced, or at least impelled, these early Cherokee settlers to move west, such as the failure, from the part of the United States, to keep the conditions of the Treaty of Hopewell (1785), which established a western boundary that was disputed by white settlers, forcing the signing of a new treaty (the Treaty of Holston) in 1791. In addition, land cessions to other tribes, natural disasters, and the conflicts that were taking place in their eastern homelands, were also factors leading to their decision to move west. Even though their settlement was not easy, and they had disputes with other tribes as well as with the white settlers, it was nevertheless voluntary, and it did not involve the horrors of the "Trail of Tears." Based on these reasons, I do believe that they made the right choice.