177k views
0 votes
Read the passage from A Doll’s House.

Mrs. Linde: Listen to me, Nora dear. Haven't you been a little bit imprudent?

Nora: [sits up straight] Is it imprudent to save your husband's life?

Mrs. Linde: It seems to me imprudent, without his knowledge, to—

Nora: But it was absolutely necessary that he should not know! My goodness, can't you understand that? It was necessary he should have no idea what a dangerous condition he was in. It was to me that the doctors came and said that his life was in danger, and that the only thing to save him was to live in the south. Do you suppose I didn't try, first of all, to get what I wanted as if it were for myself? I told him how much I should love to travel abroad like other young wives; I tried tears and entreaties with him; I told him that he ought to remember the condition I was in, and that he ought to be kind and indulgent to me; I even hinted that he might raise a loan. That nearly made him angry, Christine. He said I was thoughtless, and that it was his duty as my husband not to indulge me in my whims and caprices—as I believe he called them. Very well, I thought, you must be saved—and that was how I came to devise a way out of the difficulty—

Mrs. Linde: And did your husband never get to know from your father that the money had not come from him?

Nora: No, never. Papa died just at that time. I had meant to let him into the secret and beg him never to reveal it. But he was so ill then—alas, there never was any need to tell him.

Mrs. Linde: And since then have you never told your secret to your husband?

Nora: Good Heavens, no! How could you think so? A man who has such strong opinions about these things! And besides, how painful and humiliating it would be for Torvald, with his manly independence, to know that he owed me anything! It would upset our mutual relations altogether; our beautiful happy home would no longer be what it is now.

Which statement best compares Nora and Mrs. Linde’s traits?

Nora believes that lying with good intentions is fine, while Mrs. Linde believes that lying to one’s husband is wrong.
Nora believes that it is never prudent for a wife to tell her husband what she does with money, while Mrs. Linde thinks that only small lies are acceptable.
Mrs. Linde is a spendthrift, while Nora is frugal with the money she is given and reports back to her husband about every penny.
Mrs. Linde is frugal and dishonest, while Nora spends a lot and is honest with her husband about where she gets money for extras.

User Xoppa
by
5.6k points

2 Answers

2 votes

Nora believes that lying with good intentions is fine, while Mrs. Linde believes that lying to one’s husband is wrong.

In the passage it is clear that Nora lied to her husband about his condition and the way in which she secured a loan. She felt that it was necessary to do so in order to save her husband's life. Mrs. Linde, on the other hand, does not seem to think that these lies were a good idea since Nora feels that it is necessary to defend her actions to Mrs. Linde. Option B is wrong because of the reasons option A is correct. Options C and D are also wrong. There is nothing here to suggest that either woman is a spendthrift or frugal.

User Bentech
by
5.2k points
0 votes

The sentence that best compares Nora and Mrs. Linde’s traits is

Nora believes that lying with good intentions is fine, while Mrs. Linde believes that lying to one’s husband is wrong.

User Jim Carr
by
5.3k points