95.2k views
2 votes
Why did james madison believe that a system of federalism based on voluntary compliance would always fail?

User Amater
by
5.1k points

1 Answer

5 votes

James Madison believed that a system of federalism based on voluntary compliance would always fail because of the following reasons:

-Each state legislature contained "courtiers of popularity" who would actively oppose particular policies;

-Experience proved that states would never uniformly comply with national requests;

-Doubts about each other's commitment to policies would clog the federal system.

User Thierry Boileau
by
4.7k points