Question

Read the counterclaim.

Opponents of using tablets as a replacement for textbooks point out the high cost of implementing a system of this technology in a school system.

Which statements are examples of a fair and logical rebuttal to the counterclaim? Select two options.

These opponents point to the nearly 60-dollar difference in cost per pupil to a school district, which, in their defense, is quite significant.
While tablets are expensive, most buyers can save money in the long run by purchasing e-textbooks instead of print books.
The bottom line is that everything costs money, so complaining about the cost of tablets is pointless and unnecessary, especially when student growth is at stake.
However, the amount of money districts spend on paper used for copies, which tablets would largely replace, balances the implementation cost.
Most students find tablets fun and easy to use, all but guaranteeing an easy transition from print books.

Answer 1

While tablets are expensive, most buyers can save money in the long run by purchasing e-textbooks instead of print books.

However, the amount of money districts spend on paper used for copies, which tablets would largely replace, balances the implementation cost.

The counterclaim goes against the claim by stating that using tablets is not cost effective for replacing textbooks. The rebuttal needs to address this issue of cost and show how the cost is either worth it, or not actually as much as the opponents think. The first option which talks about the 60-dollar difference only furthers the counterclaim; it does not provide a rebuttal. The second option about purchasing e-textbooks shows how the tablets can actually save money "in the long run". This rebuts the counterclaim by showing that the cost is not as high as one might think long term. The third option is simply inappropriate. The tone is too informal and it doesn't provide any facts. It just sounds like a whiny teenager. The last option shows how the tablets will save money in other areas, thus balancing the cost and making it cost effective in the long run.

Answer 2

The first and third options are the correct ones. A fair and logical counterclaim is one that directly addresses the counterargument, and is well supported with examples or a simple explanation. The correct options fulfill these requirements, while the other options lack logical support, and seem to be too personal rather than objective. Also, they do not make direct reference to the counterargument.