Remark
The anion will take on electrons. Something like Cl2 + 2e- ===> 2Cl- is an example.
If electrons are taken on, it is normally on the outside ring. That being the case the electrons have to spread out some to accommodate the additional electrons: the ion should increase in size and is larger than the parent atom.
The answer should be A.
B is wrong: they are not equal in size
C is wrong: The anion has to be larger to accommodate the extra electrons.
D: If there are exceptions to A, I have no idea what they are. D is incorrect. I think you are intended to choose A.