8.9k views
4 votes
I am trying to get the value of imaginary numbers. The expression is
i^2

and now if I evaluate it like this,

i^2 = (√(-1) )^2\\= -1
I get -1
Again, if I evaluate it like this,

i^2 = i * i\\= √(-1) * √(-1)\\= √(-1 * -1)\\= √(1)\\= 1\\
I get 1
So there are two values -1 and 1. Which one is correct? If either of these two is incorrect, why?

User Supr
by
8.1k points

1 Answer

5 votes

Obviously 1 ≠ -1, so both conclusions cannot be true.

The short answer is that √(ab) = √ab is always true if a and b are both non-negative integers, but not always true otherwise. The case here is one in which the identity does not apply. "√a" literally means "the positive number such that its square is a". But you're using the convention that √(-1) = i, and i is not a positive number, so this identity does not apply.

The correct result is i ² = -1.

That's not to say that the identity above is always wrong whenever a or b are not non-negative. For example,

√(-25) = √((-1) × 5²) = √(-1) × √(5²) = 5i

User Quyen
by
7.9k points

No related questions found

Welcome to QAmmunity.org, where you can ask questions and receive answers from other members of our community.

9.4m questions

12.2m answers

Categories