The error that was made is: The student used a horizontal line, rather than a have more than one x-value paired to the same y-value, so there is no horizontal line test. The relation passes the vertical line test and is a function.
How to get the error
The student used a horizontal line, rather than a have more than one x-value paired to the same y-value, so there is no horizontal line test. The relation passes the vertical line test and is a function" is incorrect. Here's a breakdown explaining the flaws in this statement:
Horizontal Line Test: Unlike the vertical line test, the horizontal line test is not a standard method used to determine if a relation is a function.