I think that the first person who came along to buy apples would have to buy 12 dozen apples at $1 per dozen. Paul’s sells one dozen, Nick sells 4 dozen, and Ben sells seven dozen. After that, Paul has 3 apples, Nick has 2, and Ben has 1. If they all sent their remaining apples at a price of $3, Paul would earn 9 more dollars, Nick would earn 6, and Ben would earn three. That puts them each with a profit of $10.