476,229 views
12 votes
12 votes
Choose the best conclusion for an argument that begins, “The other members of Philip’s swim team …”

a. won their events, so Philip will win his event, too.
b. have been swimming for at least six years, so Philip has been swimming for six years, too.
c. prefer to swim in outdoor pools, so Philip prefers outdoor pools, too.
d. wear swim trunks with the school logo on them, so Philip wears them, too.

User Tyler Rinker
by
3.1k points

2 Answers

12 votes
12 votes

Final answer:

The best conclusion is option d, suggesting that Philip also wears swim trunks with the school logo, as it is the least assumptive about his abilities or preferences and follows logical team norms.

Step-by-step explanation:

Choosing the best conclusion for an argument that begins with “The other members of Philip’s swim team…” requires an understanding of logical fallacies and generalizations. The most logical and least assumptive conclusion is option d which states that, just like the other members of the swim team, Philip wears swim trunks with the school logo on them. This conclusion is based on an observable characteristic common to team members that doesn't make assumptions about skills or preferences, and it follows the general premise that members of a team often follow a uniform dress code.

Options a, b, and c are more assumptive and jump to conclusions about Philip's performance, experience, and personal preferences without any provided data to back up these claims. For example, assuming that Philip has been swimming for six years or that he will win his event based purely on the actions or success of his teammates would be a logical fallacy known as 'hasty generalization'. Likewise, personal preferences such as liking outdoor pools cannot be reliably inferred from information about what others prefer. Therefore, these options are less logically sound than the practical assumption related to team attire.

User SupaOden
by
2.9k points
8 votes
8 votes

Answer:

d. wear swim trunks with the school logo on them, so Philip wears them, too.

Step-by-step explanation:

User Hamed Baziyad
by
3.0k points