157k views
4 votes
Would you want Odysseus to be your leader? Use evidence from the text to support your analysis.

User FnCzar
by
4.0k points

2 Answers

4 votes

Answer:

Yes he would make a good leader

Step-by-step explanation:

Odysseus has lost all of his mens, but his compassion toward them makes him a good leader. By caring these mens, Odysseus uses his intelligence and bravery to overcome obstacles which they meet, even if he could not can't save all of them.

User TomCobo
by
4.4k points
0 votes

Answer:

This is an interesting question and certainly one that is up to a certain degree of interpretation. On one hand, it might be easy to argue that Odysseus is not a good leader, considering that all his men get killed over the course of their voyage. Much of this is the result of Odysseus's own pride, seeing as it is his boastfulness that results in the punishing wrath of Poseidon. If he had put the needs of his crew first, rather than needing to boast to Polyphemus, much harm could have been avoided. Furthermore, Odysseus could have done a better job communicating with his crew. If he had simply told them what was in the bag that Aeolus had given them, they would not have prematurely opened it and could have safely sailed home.

However, I might still argue that Odysseus is a good leader in spite of all this. Even in the face of all their hardships, he never gives up their goal of reaching home. He truly cares about his crew, for instance, going out of his way to see that the spirit of...

Step-by-step explanation:

User Dmitryvim
by
4.5k points