236,763 views
6 votes
6 votes
A simple question

1. Why x/∞=0 for x real numbers. can you explain it?
2.why x/0 for x real numbers is infinity (∞)?

STOP COPY PASTE THIS IS NOT A SERIOUS QUESTION BUT BECAUSE I AM CURIOUS!
DON'T ANSWER JUST FOR A POINTS BUT TO HELP PEOPLE!​

User Mustafagonul
by
2.4k points

1 Answer

24 votes
24 votes

Neither of these statements are true.

x/∞ = 0 is a nonsensical statement. It's more accurate to say


\displaystyle \lim_(y\to\infty) \frac xy = 0

for any real number x. The important bit is that y is an arbitrarily large number as it approaches ∞. To convince yourself that this expression approaches 0 as y gets larger and larger, try fixing x and pick any increasing sequence of numbers for y.

For example, let x = 1 and take y from the sequence of increasing powers of 10, {10, 10², 10³, …}, which grows without bound. Then

1/10 = 0.1

1/10² = 0.01

1/10³ = 0.001

and so on. Naturally, the larger the power of 10 and thus the larger y gets, the closer x/y gets to 0.

Similarly, x/0 is nonsense, but the "limit-ized" version of the claim is also incorrect. For any fixed real number x, the limit


\displaystyle \lim_(y\to0) \frac xy

does not exist. Suppose x > 0. If y approaches 0 from above, then y > 0 and x/y > 0 and


\displaystyle \lim_(y\to0^+) \frac xy = +\infty

which you can convince yourself is true by reversing the example from before. Let x = 1 and take y from the sequence of decreasing powers of 10, {1/10, 1/10², 1/10³, …}, which converges to 0. Then

1/(1/10) = 10

1/(1/10²) = 100

1/(1/10³) = 1000

and so on. The smaller y gets (while still being positive), the larger x/y becomes.

But now suppose y < 0 and that y approaches 0 from below. Then x/y < 0, and


\displaystyle \lim_(y\to0^-) \frac xy = -\infty

The limits from either side do not match, so the limit as y approaches 0 does not exist.

You can use the same reasoning for when x < 0.

The case of x = 0 is special, however. Since y is approaching 0, it's never actually the case that y = 0. 1/y is then some non-zero real number, and multiplying it by x = 0 makes x/y = 0. Then


\displaystyle \lim_(y\to0) \frac 0y = 0

So in general,


\displaystyle \lim_(y\to0) \frac xy = \begin{cases}0 &amp; \text{if }x = 0 \\ \text{does not exist} &amp; \text{otherwise}\end{cases}

User Massimo
by
2.5k points