60,776 views
16 votes
16 votes
Why are scientists not able to agree on whether or not viruses are alive?

a. Viruses cannot evolve but can infect living cells.
b. Viruses cannot reproduce inside living cells but can evolve.
c. Viruses cannot infect living cells but can live independently.
d. Viruses cannot live independently but can reproduce inside living cells.​

User Lameek
by
2.7k points

2 Answers

14 votes
14 votes

Final answer:

Viruses are not considered living because they cannot reproduce or carry out metabolic processes without a host, do not maintain homeostasis, and are not made of cells. Despite having genetic material and the ability to evolve, these characteristics are not sufficient for viruses to be classified as living organisms. (Option b)

Step-by-step explanation:

Scientists debate whether viruses are alive because they exhibit some but not all characteristics of living organisms. Viruses contain genetic material, like DNA and RNA, and exhibit the capacity to evolve. However, they do not qualify as living because they are not made of cells, cannot maintain homeostasis, lack a metabolism, and cannot initiate replication without a host. Essentially, viruses are acellular entities that require a host cell's machinery to reproduce, making them distinct from living organisms that can grow, metabolize, and reproduce independently.

A virus is basically genetic material encased in a protein coat, and is far simpler than even the simplest prokaryotic cell. Although viruses can evolve, demonstrating a key hallmark of living organisms, their inability to carry out necessary life functions on their own puts them in a grey area, challenging the traditional definition of life. As a result, many scientists do not classify viruses as living entities.

User Kieran Benton
by
3.2k points
18 votes
18 votes

Answer:

A .Viruses cannot evolve but can infect living cells.

User Mike Goodwin
by
2.8k points
Welcome to QAmmunity.org, where you can ask questions and receive answers from other members of our community.