430,286 views
35 votes
35 votes
Write a paragraph in which you summarize The Invisible Red String and Message in a Bottle and compare and contrast their structures.

User Yoan
by
2.6k points

2 Answers

9 votes
9 votes

Final answer:

In summary, comparing “The Invisible Red String” and “Message in a Bottle” in a paragraph involves summarizing the texts briefly before deeply analyzing the nuanced thematic and structural differences. The focus should be on how each story uniquely approaches similar themes, using examples such as settings, narrators, and symbols to illustrate the comparison.

Step-by-step explanation:

Comparing and contrasting the structures of “The Invisible Red String” and “Message in a Bottle” reveals a common narrative strategy. While summary is essential, the focus in such analysis should be on the broader thematic and structural elements of the stories. For instance, much like Marshall contrasts films, displaying how one may implement similar themes differently, these texts may be scrutinized to understand the contrasting methods of conveying universal concepts by different authors or in different eras. The right approach is to identify similarities that justify the comparison, before honing in on the differences.

When crafting a comparison-and-contrast paragraph, one useful structure begins with a working topic sentence that points out a major similarity followed by a major difference. The summarize-then-analyze method is exemplified by referencing settings, narrators, and authors in the opening, as seen in an analysis of “The Great Gatsby.” Here, summarization gives way to a discussion of setting's significance to themes—symbolism being integral to the thematic delivery. This is akin to evaluating, for instance, how virtual learning and face-to-face learning are framed or how The Great Gatsby utilizes symbolism, succinctly introduced in the introductory paragraph.

To adequately address the question, focusing on the content and delivery of both stories, while avoiding excessive summarization, would yield a deeper understanding of the distinct narrative structures and their effects.

User Cheeming
by
2.8k points
8 votes
8 votes

Answer:

Ju-Lin is a young Chinese girl living in poverty with her family. When her family must sell her to make ends meet, a traditional Chinese matchmaker buys her to serve as her apprentice. When she got to the house, she was told “First when I am home, you must help me with the cooking and cleaning around the house. When I am traveling, you must accompany me to help carry mt things. In return, you shall have enough to eat and have a small allowance each month. Is that understood.” And after a bit of time Moi-Yun had some clients later that day Ju-Lin ask Moi-Yun “What is the secret of your amazing success, mistress?” Moi-Yun replied with “There is no magic to this Ju-Lin helping people make the right choice in a partner is my passion in life. As the story goes, even at birth, that old matchmaker, God in heaven, ties an invisible red string around the foot of a boy and a girl destined to spend their lives together as husband and wife. No matter the distance or the circumstances, nothing can break this string.” A cople of weeks passed by and a matron came and knocked on the door when Ju-Lin opened the door there was a disgruntled matron. He came inside he talked to Moi-Yun saying “my son is stubborn, and he will not take any women in marring. None of the women in the five naborhoods do not meet his requirements he wants a woman with long peasant feet, and I need someone to tell his there is no women to meet his requirements. So, Ju-Lin the next day went off on her journey to talk to the boy. When she made it, the son just got back from a walk. The matron said "my son, I told you your expectations were unreasonable! Now you will hat to listen to the words of the most respected moi-yun of all five provinces. She couldn’t come in person, but you will hear from her assistant. You should pay close attention, for I have gone through a lot of trouble to moment, but I shall be back shortly.” And she gave him advice and change his lower his expectations.

I think this story is trying to say never have to high requirements or you will not get what you want. I think that the way the story updates the character type or story pattern means you must change.

Message In A Bottle

Christy Dooley is on a famine ship headed to America from Ireland. Just before the St. John reaches Massachusetts, though, it wrecks. He wants to make sure his mother knows what happened to him, so he puts a message and his St. Christopher medal in a bottle and tosses it overboard.

I think this story is trying to say never be forgotten. I think that the way the story updates the character type or story pattern means he loves his mother a lot .

Note: Dont Copy Take Some Words And When You Take Some Of It Use Your Own Words

User Nithin Mohan
by
3.1k points