66.2k views
1 vote
Was Alexander the Great wicked or heroic? Take the role of a historian. Write a brief essay or persuasive speech that explains how you see Alexander the Great. Be sure to use facts to support your position. You can compare him to other famous rulers to strengthen your argument.

2 Answers

6 votes

Final answer:

Alexander the Great was a military genius and culturally influential leader, but his legacy is complex due to his imperialist conquests. It is important to weigh his role in spreading Greek culture against the violence of his military campaigns. The debate over his character reflects broader questions about imperialism and leadership in history.

Step-by-step explanation:

Debating whether Alexander the Great was wicked or heroic entails a nuanced examination of historical records. Alexander was a military genius and a courageous leader, having been tutored by Aristotle and inspired by mythical heroes like Achilles. His conquests greatly expanded the Macedonian territory, spreading Greek culture through Hellenization across the Persian Empire and beyond. Despite his remarkable military and political successes, his methods were not without controversy, such as the destruction of Persepolis and the imposition of Greek customs on conquered peoples.

On one hand, Alexander's ability to win the loyalty of not only his Macedonian countrymen but also Greeks and Persians is noteworthy. On the other hand, historians must contend with the violent and imperialist nature of his conquests. When judging Alexander's character, it is vital to balance his role as both a unifier who promoted cultural exchange and as a conqueror whose campaigns caused suffering and destruction.

Comparing Alexander to other eminent rulers such as Julius Caesar or Genghis Khan highlights the complexity of his legacy. Like them, he exhibited exceptional leadership and strategic acumen, but also shared a capacity for ruthless conquest. Ultimately, whether Alexander is seen as wicked or heroic can depend on one's perspective on imperialism, warfare, and cultural assimilation in historical context.

User Brent Morrow
by
7.0k points
7 votes

Answer:

b

Step-by-step explanation:

User Jvdneste
by
6.9k points